The scientist who created Dolly the sheep believes anyone tempted to have their pet cloned should think again.

Even a genetically identical dog or cat would probably be disappointingly different from its original counterpart, claims Sir Ian Wilmut.

Ian and Dolly
Professor Sir Ian Wilmut with Dolly the sheep.

He said: “Before they start they should recognise it won’t be the same.

“I have a dog. If we had a clone that had been brought up under different circumstances, its personality would be different, apart from anything else.”

No guarantees

Cloning could not guarantee producing a carbon copy, even in appearance, he added.

His dog was a tri-coloured cavalier King Charles spaniel, which was “white, brown and gingery”.

However, Prof Wilmut explained: “If she was cloned, almost certainly that coat pattern will be different, even if it was a genetically identical twin, because it all depends on movement of cells during foetal development.

“In appearance, and certainly personality, it’s very likely to be different.”

On a superficial level, a new animal bought from a pet shop would probably be as good a match for a lost companion as a clone, he added.


Prof Wilmut led the team that created Dolly, the first mammal to be cloned from an adult cell, at the University of Edinburgh’s Roslin Institute on 5 July, 1996.

Britain’s first cloned dog, a dachshund named mini-Winnie, hit the headlines in 2014. She was copied from her “mother”, a 12-year-old dachshund nearing the end of her life, by scientists in South Korea.

Owner Rebecca Smith won a contest to have the £60,000 procedure carried out for free.

View your activity >

Leave a Reply

Be the First to Comment!

Notify of


related content

A leading authority on Schmallenberg virus is warning farm vets to be prepared for the possibility of a springtime spike in cases of abnormal births and deformities in sheep and cattle.

4 mins

Scientists believe they may have identified the mystery cause of “shaking piglets” – cases of which have been reported in Europe and abroad since the 1920s.

The National Equine Forum (NEF) will be celebrating its 25th event on 2 March at the Institution of Mechanical Engineers in London.

4 mins

Suzanne Rogers reports on the results and feedback from a questionnaire with owners at the annual event held in Cumbria.

18 mins

Scientists at The University of Edinburgh’s Roslyn Institute say the advances have the potential to improve the quality of UK farmed pigs and make them more resilient to disease.

3 mins

A mobile app has been developed to show budding practitioners what it's like to be both a student and qualified veterinarian – and aid their transition to vet school.