A veterinary surgeon accused of clinical failings in relation to his treatment of a cat that later died, and of keeping poor and misleading clinical records, has seen the charges against him dropped by the RCVS Disciplinary Committee (DC).

Charges against retired vet Duncan Davidson were dropped by the RCVS Disciplinary Committee after being found “not proven”.

The DC heard the case against Duncan Davidson, who was the sole practitioner and owner of Mitcham Veterinary Clinic, south London until his retirement from clinical practice in November 2014.


The first charge against Dr Davidson alleged, between 7 November 2013 and 13 December 2013, he had failed to provide adequate care to Ameira, an Egyptian Mau cat.

The charge was in four parts, claiming Dr Davidson had:

  1. inappropriately administered corticosteroids
  2. failed to administer adequate fluid therapy
  3. discharged the cat to its owner suggesting a referral when he should have suggested or arranged a same-day referral
  4. failed to communicate the urgency of referral or further investigation of the cat’s condition to her owner

The second charge was, between 7 November 2013 and 17 January 2014, he dishonestly made retrospective alterations to Ameira’s clinical records and failed to keep clear, accurate and detailed clinical records.

From the outset Dr Davidson, who attended the hearing, did not admit the charges against him and denied his conduct, if found proven, constituted serious professional misconduct.

‘Troubling aspects’

The DC found the first part of the first charge proven, the following two parts were adjudged “not proven” and the committee was unable to be satisfied on the evidence to the necessary standard of proof required on the fourth part of the first charge.

The DC said although there were some “troubling aspects” about the second charge, it found it “not proven” and noted Dr Davidson had enjoyed a unblemished professional record for over 40 years.

View your activity >

Leave a Reply

Be the First to Comment!

Notify of


related content

Ian Ramsey, Susanna Spence and Emma Roberts having all been involved in a desoxycortone pivalate clinical trial, provide a review of hypoadrenocorticism, as well as suggestions for management in dogs.

29 mins

An RCVS disciplinary committee hearing has been adjourned indefinitely after respondent Roger Meacock agreed to amend his website to make it compliant with his professional responsibilities.

3 mins

The BVA is looking for nominations for the 2017-18 junior vice-president post, as well as three members of its newly formed electoral college.

5 mins

To mark the launch of the 2017 BVA In Practice CPD programme, the association has teamed up with programme sponsor Subaru to find a vet to give one of its Outback models the most intense test drive possible.

3 mins

The college celebrated its latest milestone with a weekend of events including an ethical debate, talks, a film screening and a glamorous gala dinner.

4 mins

UK vets are putting extra pressure on themselves by failing to make the best use of the skills and experience of their veterinary nursing teams, according to business consultancy Onswitch.

4 mins