Image ©

Following the devastating news of the Germanwings crash last week, the co-pilot’s torn-up sick note and the early implication of mental health issues (later suspected to instead be eyesight-related), I witnessed a shocking flare-up of defence regarding mental health on social media.

My gut reaction was of absolute disgust. Whether said sick note referred to mental illness or not, the co-pilot was not 100% mentally sound, otherwise he would not have deliberately crashed an aeroplane into the Alps, killing 149 innocent people.

An article I read describing the rescue efforts to retain the pieces of the bodies (explosion on impact meant there were no bodies intact) was particularly distressing. And yet people preached online, directly referring to the plane crash, that people with clinical depression should be able to hold such jobs. I’m not advocating denying sufferers of severe mental health problems the right to work – but perhaps not in a job that could result in this sort of sickening situation. Can we have some context please?

While a vet may not have it in his or her power to destroy innocent lives to such an extent as pilots, how does this translate? Vets have access to dangerous drugs that could have drastic consequences if used wrongly due to mental instability, and perhaps provide a more accessible option of suicide than the non-medical general public. They also carry responsibility during surgery or other procedures with the potential to act inappropriately with implications on the lives of animals in their care.

Airplane seatbelt
Image © hangxu

You wouldn’t necessarily get on a plane if you were told the pilot had severe clinical depression, so would you leave your dog requiring general anaesthesia with a vet who is?

I think where the confusion has occurred is that word that gets thrown around too easily regarding mental health: “stigma”.

There is a certain stigma regarding mental health, but instead of ranting about discrimination due to mental health, a step forward would be acceptance.

One of the major factors in suicide within the veterinary profession is vets themselves not admitting they need help. In order to prevent professionals (in any sector) slipping through the net and putting on a brave face with unexpected devastating consequences, we need them to accept that they are unwell or stressed in order to take a step towards gaining help to get back on track.

To do this in a veterinary context, we need to remove the fear of being prevented from practising. The words “fitness to practice”, even within vet school, send a ripple of fear through one’s skin. I’m aware of students who have deliberately concealed medical conditions from the faculty through fear of being thrown out. I can only imagine this is carried through to qualified vets, frightened of “being struck off”.

It shouldn’t be that way.Germanwings logo #indeepsorrow

The profession as a whole needs to work towards distinguishing clearly between taking a break from practice to get yourself better and being irreversibly banned from practising as a vet. We need to make it “okay” for vets to admit they need help to have any hope of reducing suicide, among other consequences of mental ill-health, within the profession.


View your activity >

Leave a Reply

4 Comments on "Crash prevention"

Notify of

Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
1 year 6 months ago
Can’t help but think that this is coming from someone who has never been in a situation of “mental instability” as you put it. What he did was terrible and wrong. But would you tar everyone suffering from the same condition with the same brush? Depression isn’t a one size fits all blanket diagnosis. The fact that he was suicidal is separate from him being depressed. You’re saying that people who are depressed and coping with it should be discriminated against the same as those who might me suicidal. Why do we have to over analyse this? He was a… Read more »

related content

Nasotracheal intubation can be used as an easy, less traumatic method of rabbit intubation when … more

2 mins

Several species of lice live on chickens and cement their eggs on the base of feather shafts.

2 mins

It is harder to correlate the grade of a heart murmur with the severity of the underlying heart problem in cats than it is in dogs. Some quite loud murmurs may occur with relatively small defects.

2 mins

Four parameters can be measured to objectively assess dehydration. PCV and Total Protein should be … more

2 mins

Clinical examination for dehydration is one method used for assessing whether or not an animal … more

2 mins

Tyzzer’s disease is caused by Clostridium piliforme and can cause severe disease in many animal … more

2 mins